After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (2024)

We independently evaluate all of our recommendations. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

  • Makeup
  • Eyes

Formulas that stay put without settling into fine lines.

By

Esme Benjamin

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (1)

Esme Benjamin

Esme Benjamin is a freelance writer, editor, and podcaster based in Brooklyn, New York.

Byrdie's Editorial Guidelines

Published on November 21, 2024 03:03PM

Comments

In This Article

View All

In This Article

  • Our Top Picks
  • Reviews
  • What to Look For
  • How We Tested
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Meet Our Experts
  • Why Trust Byrdie

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (2)

TL;DR

Our overall favorite eyeliner for older women is the MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner—a smooth formula that delivers precise lines and an impressive color payoff. We also loved our best waterproof pick, Victoria Beckham's Satin Kajal Liner—a luxurious formula with gorgeous color options that stay put despite humidity, sweat, and eye-rubbing.

It’s natural to evolve your makeup selection and application techniques as your complexion matures, especially in the eye area, which can be very delicate. The skin is a little thinner and prone to crepiness. “For mature eyes, it’s not just about adding definition,” says Alyson Hoag, CEO & Founder of Authentic Beauty Makeup Salon & Brow Studio, “it’s about balance and enhancing the natural beauty of the eyes without overwhelming them,” Hoag recommends tightlining along the upper lash line to create the impression of thicker lashes. Sweeping an eyeliner flick upwards with some artful blending can also produce a lifted effect for the eye, but you’ll want to make sure the formula dries and sets promptly to avoid smudging.

To determine which eyeliner formulas are best for mature eyes, we put dozens to the test in our lab and at home, evaluating them on ease of application, formula, pigmentation, effectiveness, and longevity. We also spoke with two professional makeup artists and combined their recommendations with tester insights before crowning these the best eyeliners for older women.

What We Like

  • Fine tip for thin, precise lines

  • Intense pigmentation

  • Won’t smudge

What to Consider

  • Not super blendable

Formula: Gel pencil | Shades: 14 | Cruelty-Free: Yes

This gel pencil liner from MAC checks all the right boxes. It glides gently onto mature eyelids with no skipping, delivering a precise line and impressive color payoff that’s great for creating bold liner looks. The formula comes in 14 color options, from soft brown to bright teal, but our tester noted she did have to layer it on to reach full vibrancy and opacity, so take a more-is-more approach with this one. It’s also a waterproof formula, so you can relax knowing your liner will stay put for up to 24 hours with no smudges. Just don’t rub your eyes, or our tester says it will start to fade.

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (4)

Karla, tester: “I love the vibrant color payoff and the thin tip that allows for precise lines, whether thin or bold.”

What We Like

  • Soft texture is great for tightlining

  • Can be smudged for a smokey effect

  • Creates crisp, fine lines

What to Consider

  • Not the most pigmented formula

Formula: Pencil | Shades: 6 | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Fans of classic eyeliner pencils will love this option from Jones Road, which lives up to the promise of its name. Inspired by the dense formulas of 1970s pencils, it glides on nicely and is buildable for a strong color payoff. Our tester loved how versatile this liner is, noting that it’s capable of creating “crisp, graphic shapes” as well as smoky eye effects—especially when layered over a shadow. The liner comes in six shades, including monochromatic shimmer options for more dramatic or creative looks.

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (6)

Ashley, tester: “My favorite feature of this eyeliner pencil is how soft it is upon application, which makes it easier to apply in between the eyelashes for a tightline look.”

What We Like

  • Doesn’t skip or tug the skin

  • Remains workable until dry

  • Buildable formula

What to Consider

  • Might smudge on hot days

Formula: Liquid | Shades: 1 | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Getting a precise line becomes more challenging when the skin on your eyelids is less firm than it used to be. That’s when a fine-tipped liquid liner like this one comes into play. It applies easily without skipping or tugging, and you can choose how thick and dark the formula appears—apply light pressure for sharp, fine lines or add more pressure for a thicker, bolder look. Our tester appreciated that the liner remains moist and “workable” for some time, making it easier to fix mistakes or build up to your desired intensity. Once it’s dry, the brand says the waterproof formula should remain smudge-proof and long-lasting, but our tester did experience some transfer on a particularly hot day.

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (8)

Taylore, tester (not pictured): “This pen created precise lines and went on smooth without skipping or tugging.”

What We Like

  • Glides on smoothly

  • Makes precision application easy

  • Creamy, blendable formula

  • Buildable pigmentation

What to Consider

  • Can fade throughout the day

Formula: Gel pencil | Shades: 7 | Cruelty-Free: No

The consistency of the Lancôme Drama Liqui-Pencil is Smooth, creamy, and “luxurious” according to our tester—perfect for mature eyes. It glides on beautifully, creating precise lines with no tugging whatsoever. Our tester also appreciated how easy it was to blend—you can even diffuse it to create an eyeshadow effect if desired. She found the first swipe slightly subtle for her tastes but created a more dramatic effect by layering the formula. The longevity of this liner was impressive, too—it lasted all daywithout smudging, and she experienced just the tiniest amount of fading.

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (10)

Karla, tester: “This eyeliner feels luxurious, and the application is effortless. It glides on, and I truly appreciate that.”

What We Like

  • Rich, vibrant pigment

  • Smooth and seamless application

  • Stays put all day

  • Creates thick and fine lines easily

What to Consider

  • Soft texture can snap and smudge

Formula: Gel pencil | Shades: 5 | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Pat McGrath Labs is known for its artistic flair and richly pigmented formulations, and the brand’s PermaGel eye pencil is no exception. This liner comes in five classic colors, including black, brown, and blue—in gorgeous matte or shimmer finishes—and has an unparalleled color payoff. Our tester loved how vibrant the liner was from the first swipe. She also appreciated the smooth and seamless application process; the creamy formula makes creating thin and thick lines a breeze. The liner has a lovely creamy texture, but that comes with a downside—don’t press too hard, or the tip might snap, and beware of smudging when rubbing your eyes.

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (12)

Karla, tester: “The pigmentation of the PermaGel Eyeliner Pencil is impressive. The color is vibrant and true to the advertised shade. You need about one to two swipes for full pigmentation.”

What We Like

  • Waterproof formula stays put

  • Luxurious, creamy texture

  • Beautiful color range

  • Sponge tip for diffusing

What to Consider

  • Not the easiest to sharpen

Formula: Pencil | Shades: 19 | Cruelty-Free: Yes

When you’ve put effort into perfecting an eyeliner, you want it to stay pristine all day, and with this waterproof formula from Victoria Beckham, it really will. Our tester was amazed by its staying power—humidity, sweat, and even eye-rubbing were no match for this formula. It comes in 19 unique shades, including shimmer and glitter liner options that lend themselves to creative looks, and the sponge-tip end allows you to blend and diffuse effortlessly. According to our tester, the creamy texture makes the application feel like “gliding silk across your skin.” Using this liner is a luxurious experience from start to finish.

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (14)

Karla, tester: “I wore it to an outdoor event, and it stayed put all day. The color remained vibrant without smudging, even if I accidentally rubbed my eyes. It's genuinely impressive how well it holds up against humidity and sweat.”

What to Look for When Buying Eyeliner for Mature Eyes

  • Formula Type: While the formula you choose comes down to preference at the end of the day, certain types are more helpful when dealing with crepey lids. Hoag prefers a fine-tipped, quick-drying liquid for tightlining, while celebrity makeup artist Tonya Riner recommends a gel pencil that’s easy to blend out. You might also want to consider picking a waterproof formula that’s long-lasting and smudge-proof, even on wrinkled skin.
  • Color: For mature eyes, Riner recommends sticking with softer colors like gray, navy, and warm browns rather than stark black shades. “They subtly define the eyes while enhancing their natural shape and color,” she explains.
  • Ingredients: Eyes can become more sensitive as we age. Pick a formula containing hydrating ingredients like shea or cocoa butter to help soothe and moisturize the delicate skin around the eye without irritating it.

How We Tested Eyeliners for Mature Eyes

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (15)

To determine the best eyeliners for older women, our editorial team spent hours digging through several of our eyeliner tests and speaking with experts for their advice. After making several selections, we evaluated each formula on application, formula, pigmentation, effectiveness, and longevity. Finally, armed with our insights and expert recommendations, we landed on our top picks for this list.

FAQ

  • How should you apply eyeliner to mature eyes?

    Our experts agree that older women should take a more minimal approach to eyeliner, with precise application and a lighter touch. Hoag recommends tightlining—applying liner right at the lash line—as a useful technique. “It subtly defines the eyes by filling in the upper lash line, creating the appearance of fuller lashes and brighter eyes,” she explains. Riner advises using an angled brush to sweep the liner up and out. “This is especially important if the outer corners of your eyes have a downward tilt, she says. “Be sure to stop just before the end of the lash line, and cheat the line upward for a lifted effect.”

  • How do you prevent eyeliner from smudging on mature eyes?

    Start by prepping your eyelids using a good eye primer, which will create a smooth surface for application and hold your liner in place for longer. When it comes to formula, opt for a pencil or gel liner, which both set quicker than liquid. “Just make sure you finish one eye completely before starting the next,” says Riner, or you’ll lose the window of workability.

  • How can I make my eyes look bigger with eyeliner as I age?

    Eyes can start to appear smaller as we age, but with some handy eyeliner tricks you can create the illusion of bigger eyes. As we’ve established, tightlining the upper lash line will help to define your eyes without overwhelming them. Try adding a white liner on the bottom waterline to open up and brighten your eyes and experiment with gently smudging your line for a softer, more open-eyed appearance.

Meet Our Experts

To narrow down our list and find out what to consider when purchasing eyeliner for older women, we spoke to experts, including:

  • Alyson Hoag, CEO & Founder of the award-winning Authentic Beauty Makeup Salon & Brow Studio in Atlanta.
  • Tonya Riner, a celebrity beauty expert and makeup artist with thirty years of experience in the industry.

Why Trust Byrdie

Esme Benjamin is a freelance writer, editor, and podcaster based in Brooklyn, New York. Esme joined Byrdie as a freelance writer and editor in 2023, covering the best tried and tested products in the beauty space.

According to ourDiversity Pledge, 15% of products in our newly published market roundups will feature Black-owned and/or Black-founded brands. At the time of publishing, we were not able to find any eyeliners for mature skin from a Black-owned and/or Black-founded business. If you know of one we should consider, please email us atcontact@byrdie.comand we will evaluate the product ASAP.

After Dozens of Tests, We Found the 6 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated:

Views: 5522

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.